Tim Hortons is widely known across the United States for its coffee, donuts, and quick breakfast options. But beyond the regular menu lies something even more exciting for loyal fans — the Tim Hortons Secret Menu.
The Tim Hortons secret menu includes customized drinks, off-menu food hacks, and creative combinations that aren’t officially listed but can be ordered if you know what to ask for. These items are popular among regular customers and often shared through social media and word-of-mouth.
In this guide, we’ll explore the Tim Hortons Secret Menu in the USA (2026), including popular secret items, estimated prices, how to order them, nutrition considerations, and FAQs.
What Is the Tim Hortons Secret Menu?
A secret menu refers to unofficial menu items created by customers or employees using existing ingredients. These items are not displayed on menu boards or mobile apps but can often be made upon request.
Secret menu items are popular because they:
- Offer custom flavors
- Feel exclusive
- Let customers personalize their orders
- Add excitement to routine visits
At Tim Hortons USA locations, availability depends on ingredients, staff familiarity, and store policy.
Tim Hortons Secret Menu Prices (USA 2026)
Below is a list of popular Tim Hortons secret menu items with estimated prices in the United States. Prices may vary by location, state taxes, and customization.
| Secret Menu Item | Description | Estimated Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Got Milk? | Chocolate milk added to an Iced Capp | $3.49 |
| Cheap Mocha | Half coffee, half hot chocolate | $2.49 |
| Cheesy Croissant | Heated croissant with cheese | $1.99 |
| Buttery Croissant | Croissant with extra butter | $1.99 |
| Cheesy Butter Croissant | Cheese + butter croissant | $2.29 |
| Chocolate Explosion | Hot chocolate with whipped cream | $2.99 |
| Minted Cappuccino | Iced Capp with mint flavor shot | $4.49 |
| Warm Donut | Any donut warmed up | $1.29 |
| Hashbrown Sandwich | Hashbrown added to breakfast sandwich | $3.79 |
| Peanut Butter Bagel | Raisin bagel with peanut butter | $2.49 |
| Mixed Tea | Two tea flavors mixed | $0.30 extra |
| Grilled Cheese w/ Veggies | Extra veggies in grilled cheese | $5.79 |
| Veggie Sandwich | Custom vegetable sandwich | $5.99 |
| Extra Patties | Extra egg or sausage | Price varies |
| Whipped Cream Add-On | Whipped cream on any drink | Price varies |
| Make It a Panini | Pressed sandwich style | $4.99 |
⚠️ Secret menu prices are approximate and depend on ingredient availability and customization.
Popular Tim Hortons Secret Menu Items
1. Double-Double Deluxe
An upgraded version of the classic Double-Double. Add vanilla, caramel, or hazelnut flavor shots for a richer taste.
Best for: Coffee lovers who want extra flavor without extra cost.
2. Canadian Colada
A tropical twist on the Iced Capp with coconut and pineapple flavor shots.
Best for: Summer refreshment lovers.
3. Maple Bacon Boston Cream
A creative donut hack combining Boston Cream donut + maple glaze + bacon bits (where available).
Best for: Sweet-and-savory fans.
4. Timbit Explosion
A box of Timbits topped with chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and sprinkles.
Best for: Sharing or dessert cravings.
How to Order from the Tim Hortons Secret Menu
Ordering secret menu items is simple if you follow these tips:
- Know the recipe – staff may not recognize the item name.
- Politely explain the customization.
- Order during non-rush hours for better results.
- Be flexible — availability may vary.
- Stay patient and friendly.
📌 Secret menu items usually cannot be ordered directly through the app, but you can customize drinks manually.
Are Secret Menu Items Available at All Tim Hortons Locations?
No. Availability depends on:
- Location
- Ingredient stock
- Staff familiarity
- Franchise policies
Urban locations and high-traffic stores are more likely to accommodate custom orders.
Nutritional Considerations
Most secret menu items are:
- Higher in sugar
- Higher in calories
- More indulgent than standard menu items
If you’re health-conscious:
- Request less sugar
- Choose smaller sizes
- Skip whipped cream or syrups
Secret menu items are best enjoyed as occasional treats.
Secret Menu vs Regular Menu
| Secret Menu | Regular Menu |
|---|---|
| Custom creations | Standard recipes |
| More indulgent | Balanced options |
| Not officially listed | Clearly priced |
| Requires explanation | Easy ordering |
Both menus offer great choices — the secret menu simply adds creativity and personalization.
Create Your Own Tim Hortons Secret Menu Item
Feeling adventurous? Try creating your own!
Tips:
- Mix syrups (vanilla + caramel)
- Add espresso shots
- Combine donuts or pastries
- Share your creation on social media
Some secret menu items actually start as customer inventions.
FAQs – Tim Hortons Secret Menu (USA 2026)
Can I order secret menu items through the app?
No. You’ll need to order in-store or at the drive-thru.
Are secret menu items more expensive?
Usually similar in price, but add-ons may cost extra.
Can I customize secret menu items?
Yes, as long as ingredients are available.
Are secret menu items available all day?
Most are, but some ingredients may be breakfast-only or time-restricted.
Are there healthier secret menu options?
Yes — choose reduced sugar, plant-based milk, or smaller sizes.
Conclusion
The Tim Hortons Secret Menu in the USA (2026) adds excitement, creativity, and personalization to your coffee and food experience. From hidden coffee hacks to indulgent donut creations, these off-menu items are perfect for adventurous customers who want more than the usual order.
While availability may vary, knowing what to ask for can unlock a whole new side of Tim Hortons.